Sunday Pie Shop
real, good, pie
about
the shop
Sunday Pie Shop is cottage kitchen bakery located in Maplewood, NJ focused on high quality, handmade to order pies and other goodies. We use seasonal, local, organic ingredients as much as possible.
We offer a rotating monthly menu for local pick up, custom orders & event catering.
How to get your weekly pie! Orders must be placed by Wednesday at 12pm latest for the next Saturday/Sunday Pick Up. Orders may be placed for later available dates.
Check out our upcoming events below for tastings, workshops, and pop up shops!
Upcoming events
-
Weekly Slice at General Store Cafe
Stop by to grab a slice of pie! Rotating flavor every week, available Saturday & Sunday until sold out.
1875 Springfield Ave, Maplewood, NJ
MEET SARAH
Owner & Baker
Hi! I’m Sarah, born and raised Maplewood local, and of course - pie lover.
I have always loved crafting beautiful and delicious things for people to enjoy. With a background in fine arts, third wave coffee, events management, and a long love of baking, Sunday Pie Shop was born.
After 10 year in NYC, I moved back to my hometown with my husband and little one. Becoming a mom in the height of the pandemic magnified how important it was to create joyful moments with family and friends. Whether it’s major milestones or simply a family dinner, there’s a perfect pie for every occasion, and I can’t wait to bake for you.
See what’s baking & follow along @Sunday_PieShop
