Orders must be placed by Wednesday at 12pm latest to pick up your goodies the following Saturday or Sunday (9am-4pm). Orders may be place for later dates - you’ll have a choice of “Pick Up Dates” when picking your pies. Sunday Pie Shop offers local pick up in Maplewood, NJ.

Need something for a specific time & day? Head to Custom Orders & Catering. Problems with your order? Email us at sayhi@sundaypieshop.com.